Hillsborough County (Tampa) small group health insurance costs in 2026 range from approximately $380–$490 per employee per month for Bronze HMO to $545–$690 for Gold HMO. Tampa is one of Florida's most competitive small group markets, with five or more carriers actively competing — making broker comparison shopping especially valuable. Oscar and Ambetter often offer Bronze and Silver premiums 10–20% below Florida Blue for similar coverage.
| Plan Tier | Total Monthly Premium | Employer Cost (65%) | Employee Cost (35%) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bronze HMO | $380–$490 | $247–$319 | $133–$172 |
| Silver HMO | $455–$580 | $296–$377 | $159–$203 |
| Gold HMO | $545–$690 | $354–$449 | $191–$242 |
| Bronze PPO | $455–$570 | $296–$371 | $159–$200 |
| Business Size | Annual Employer Cost Range |
|---|---|
| 2 employees | $7,104–$9,048/year |
| 5 employees | $17,760–$22,620/year |
| 10 employees | $35,520–$45,240/year |
| 20 employees | $71,040–$90,480/year |
Oscar and Ambetter typically offer the lowest Bronze and Silver HMO premiums in Hillsborough County. For a business focused on minimizing employer cost while maintaining meaningful coverage, comparing Oscar or Ambetter Silver HMO against Florida Blue Silver HMO is the most impactful step. The savings can be 10–20% on the same plan tier, with trade-offs in network breadth and member service.
Hillsborough County (Tampa) and Orange County (Orlando) are very similar in small group premium levels — typically within 3–7% of each other on comparable plan tiers. Both are mid-range Florida markets, significantly more affordable than South Florida (Broward, Miami-Dade) but slightly higher than some rural Central Florida counties.
Yes — pairing a Bronze HDHP with employer HSA contributions can lower the employer's premium cost by 20–30% versus Silver HMO while still providing meaningful benefits. Employer HSA contributions are also tax-deductible and FICA-exempt. This strategy works well for younger, healthier workforces. For mixed or older employee populations, model the total employee out-of-pocket exposure before switching from Silver.
Compare all Tampa area carriers side-by-side — no cost, no obligation.
Get My Quote