Florida small business owners have two primary paths for offering health benefits: a traditional group health plan or an Individual Coverage Health Reimbursement Arrangement (ICHRA). Both accomplish the same basic goal — helping employees access and afford health insurance — but they work in fundamentally different ways, and the better choice depends on your workforce, budget, and administrative tolerance.
This article explains how each option works, compares them directly, and walks through the situations where one clearly outperforms the other.
Related reading
ICHRA stands for Individual Coverage Health Reimbursement Arrangement. Congress authorized it through the 2019 HHS/Treasury rule, and it became available to employers on January 1, 2020. Unlike older HRA structures, ICHRA can be offered by employers of any size — there is no minimum or maximum headcount.
Here is how it works in practice:
The allowance is entirely employer-defined. There is no IRS minimum or maximum for most businesses. An employer might set an allowance of $300 per month for part-time employees and $600 per month for full-time employees — or any other amounts that reflect the business's budget and competitive positioning.
Get a side-by-side analysis for your specific workforce — no obligation, no pressure.
A traditional group health plan operates differently. You work with a licensed broker or directly with a carrier to select a plan — or a small menu of plans — and enroll your eligible employees. The carrier prices the policy based on your group's demographics, location, and in some cases the group's claims history.
Employees typically pay a portion of the premium through payroll deduction. The employer pays the remainder. If the group has a bad claims year, renewal premiums can increase significantly — sometimes 15–25% or more. The employer absorbs that cost increase or passes it to employees through higher payroll deductions.
Group plans also come with participation requirements. Most Florida carriers require that at least 70% of eligible employees who do not have other qualifying coverage (such as a spouse's employer plan) enroll in the group plan. If participation falls below that threshold, the carrier can decline to issue or renew the policy.
| Factor | Group Health Plan | ICHRA |
|---|---|---|
| Who selects the plan | Employer | Each employee individually |
| Employer cost predictability | Variable — can spike at renewal | Fixed — you set the allowance |
| Minimum participation | Typically 70% | None |
| Employee choice | Limited to employer-selected plan(s) | Any ACA-compliant individual plan |
| ACA subsidy interaction | No interaction | Can block marketplace subsidies |
| Eligible employer sizes | Any (rates differ by size) | Any — no minimum headcount |
| Administrative burden | Moderate (plan selection, open enrollment) | Moderate (allowance tracking, reimbursement review) |
The most significant financial advantage of ICHRA is cost certainty. You commit to a dollar amount per employee per month, and that is your maximum exposure. If an employee chooses a higher-premium plan, they pay the difference out of pocket. Your budget never spikes because of group claims. For small businesses with thin margins, eliminating the unpredictability of group plan renewals is a genuine operational advantage.
Many small Florida businesses struggle to meet the 70% participation threshold required by group carriers. If several employees are covered under a spouse's plan or are on Medicare, the eligible-employee pool shrinks, and reaching 70% can become difficult. ICHRA sidesteps this entirely — even if only two employees choose to use the allowance, the arrangement remains valid.
ICHRA permits different allowance amounts for different employee classes, provided those classes are defined under the IRS rules (full-time, part-time, seasonal, geographic location, etc.). An employer with a mix of full-time office staff and part-time hourly workers can offer meaningfully different allowances to each class without violating nondiscrimination rules — as long as the distinction tracks an IRS-recognized class.
An employee who already has a preferred physician network or specific prescription needs can pick an individual plan that covers those specifically, rather than being locked into whatever the employer selected for the group. In theory, this produces better plan-to-employee matching and higher employee satisfaction with their coverage.
This is frequently underestimated. Selecting an individual health insurance plan requires comparing premiums, deductibles, copays, provider networks, drug formularies, and subsidy eligibility across dozens of options. Employees who are not comfortable with this process — or who simply do not prioritize it — may end up underinsured or in a plan that does not serve their needs well. Employers who implement ICHRA without strong employee education and decision-support resources often see lower benefit satisfaction than with a group plan, despite spending equivalent dollars.
This is the most important compliance issue employers need to understand before implementing ICHRA. Employees who are offered an ICHRA cannot simultaneously receive ACA marketplace premium tax credits (subsidies) — but only if the ICHRA offer is considered "affordable" under IRS rules.
Affordability is determined by a specific IRS formula based on the employee's self-only premium for the lowest-cost silver plan in their rating area and their household income. If your ICHRA allowance meets or exceeds that threshold, your employees are ineligible for marketplace subsidies — even if their individual plan costs more than the allowance covers.
Employees who determine the ICHRA offer is unaffordable can opt out of the ICHRA and instead take marketplace subsidies. But the employer's ICHRA offer may still technically disqualify them from subsidies even if they opt out, depending on the specific facts.
For employers with lower-wage workforces where many employees would otherwise qualify for significant marketplace subsidies, implementing ICHRA could effectively reduce employees' total benefit value. This requires careful modeling before implementation.
Florida has not expanded Medicaid under the ACA. That means adults with income below approximately 100% of the federal poverty level do not qualify for Medicaid in Florida and also do not qualify for ACA marketplace subsidies (which begin at 100% FPL). These individuals fall into a coverage gap — they cannot access subsidized marketplace plans, and they are not Medicaid-eligible.
If your workforce includes employees in this income range, an ICHRA offer may not translate into usable coverage for them. The allowance cannot be applied to Medicaid (which has no premium), and unsubsidized marketplace plans may be unaffordable even with the allowance. This is a meaningful consideration for Florida employers in industries like agriculture, food service, hospitality, and construction where wages are concentrated at the lower end.
An ICHRA (Individual Coverage Health Reimbursement Arrangement) is an employer-funded benefit in which the employer sets a fixed monthly dollar allowance per employee class. Employees use that allowance to purchase their own ACA-compliant individual health insurance and then submit documentation to be reimbursed, tax-free, up to their allowance amount. ICHRA became available on January 1, 2020.
With a traditional group plan, the employer selects a specific plan and employees enroll in that same plan. With an ICHRA, the employer sets only a dollar allowance; each employee independently selects their own plan from the individual market. The employer's cost is fixed regardless of which plans employees choose, whereas group plan costs can rise based on the group's claims experience.
It depends on whether the ICHRA offer is deemed "affordable" under IRS rules. If the ICHRA allowance meets the affordability threshold, employees cannot also receive marketplace premium tax credits (subsidies). If the ICHRA offer is unaffordable, employees can opt out of the ICHRA and take marketplace subsidies instead. Employers should model this before implementing ICHRA, especially for lower-wage workforces.
No. ICHRA has no minimum employee participation requirements. Traditional group health plans typically require that at least 70% of eligible employees enroll (or waive due to other qualifying coverage) before a carrier will issue a policy. ICHRA eliminates that barrier, making it viable for businesses where many employees may already have coverage from another source.
Florida has not expanded Medicaid under the ACA, so lower-income adults (roughly below 100% of the federal poverty level) do not qualify for Medicaid and cannot use marketplace plans with subsidies. If those employees receive an ICHRA offer, they may be unable to fully use the allowance to purchase coverage they can afford. This is a meaningful complication for Florida employers with lower-wage workforces.
Employers of any size can offer an ICHRA. There is no minimum or maximum employee count. This differs from QSEHRA, which is limited to businesses with fewer than 50 full-time equivalent employees. See our QSEHRA vs. ICHRA comparison for more detail on the differences.
Get a side-by-side analysis tailored to your workforce size, wages, and Florida market — from a licensed Florida health insurance producer.
Get My Side-by-Side Analysis