Florida small businesses have two primary paths to providing health benefits: a traditional group health insurance plan or a Health Reimbursement Arrangement (HRA). Group plans offer employer-selected coverage employees share; HRAs give employees funds to purchase their own individual coverage. Neither is universally better — the right choice depends on your employee count, budget predictability goals, and whether your team prefers plan choice flexibility.
| Feature | Group Health Plan | HRA (ICHRA/QSEHRA) |
|---|---|---|
| Minimum employees | 2 W-2 employees | 1 (ICHRA) / 1 (QSEHRA, under 50 FTEs) |
| Employer controls plan | Yes — employer selects carrier and plan | No — employees choose their own plans |
| Contribution cap | None | QSEHRA: $6,350/yr individual; ICHRA: no cap |
| Cost predictability | Moderate — annual renewal rate changes | High — employer sets fixed monthly amount |
| Employee plan choice | Limited to offered plans | Full marketplace flexibility |
| ACA subsidies for employees | N/A — group plan disqualifies subsidies | ICHRA eligible employees lose ACA subsidies |
| Tax treatment (employer) | 100% deductible (IRC §162) | 100% deductible |
| Administration complexity | Moderate | Low to moderate (QSEHRA) / Moderate (ICHRA) |
Generally no — an employer cannot offer the same employee both a group health plan and a QSEHRA or ICHRA. If you offer a group plan, employees covered by it cannot also use an ICHRA for the same coverage category. You can offer ICHRA to employees who are not eligible for the group plan (e.g., part-time employees or employees in states without group plan coverage) as long as the classes are properly defined.
With ICHRA: employees who are offered an ICHRA that provides "affordable" coverage (under the IRS affordability threshold) lose eligibility for ACA premium tax credits for their marketplace plan. With QSEHRA: employees can still receive marketplace subsidies, but the subsidy is reduced by the QSEHRA reimbursement amount. The interaction between HRAs and ACA subsidies is complex — consult a licensed broker.
A QSEHRA is often more cost-effective for very small Florida businesses. A 3-person group plan may cost $450–$575/employee/month (Silver tier) — $16,200–$20,700/year for three employees at 100% employer contribution. A QSEHRA could offer $400/month per employee ($14,400/year total) at a flat, predictable cost with no participation requirements. Compare actual quotes before deciding.
A licensed broker can compare group plan quotes and HRA costs side by side for your situation.
Get a Comparison