Jump To
Hillsborough County is the population and economic hub of the Tampa Bay region, and it offers the most robust Medicare Advantage market in Central Florida. With over a million residents and a substantial senior population, the county attracts fierce competition from both national insurers and Florida-specific carriers. That competition is good news for Medicare beneficiaries: it translates to lower premiums, richer supplemental benefits, and a wider range of plan types to choose from.
The county's healthcare infrastructure is exceptional by any measure. Tampa General Hospital is a nationally ranked academic medical center. BayCare Health System operates multiple hospitals across the region. HCA Florida Health operates major facilities in Brandon and elsewhere. AdventHealth Tampa rounds out a robust hospital landscape that most major Medicare Advantage plans are eager to include in their networks.
For Medicare-eligible Hillsborough County residents, the challenge is not finding options — it is sorting through seven or more carriers and dozens of plan variations to find the one that best fits your doctors, medications, budget, and lifestyle.
Comparing Medicare plans in Florida
Blue Cross Blue Shield of Florida (Florida Blue) offers HMO and PPO plans with a statewide provider network. Florida Blue's PPO options are especially valuable for Tampa beneficiaries who may need to see specialists at Moffitt Cancer Center or USF Health and want out-of-network flexibility as a safety net.
Humana has a strong presence in Hillsborough with HMO, PPO, and D-SNP options. Humana's $0-premium Gold Plus HMO plans have historically offered strong OTC and transportation benefits in this market.
UnitedHealthcare (AARP) offers HMO and PPO options and is popular among beneficiaries who value the Optum provider network and Renew Active fitness program. UHC also offers D-SNP plans in Hillsborough County.
Aetna (CVS Health) provides HMO and PPO options with CVS pharmacy integration that can lower drug costs for beneficiaries who use CVS locations regularly. Aetna's D-SNP plans are among the better-funded in the market for dual-eligible residents.
Molina Healthcare focuses primarily on Medicaid and dual-eligible populations. Molina's D-SNP plans in Hillsborough offer $0 premiums, robust OTC benefits, and coordinated care management for members with complex needs.
Devoted Health is a technology-forward carrier that has built a strong reputation in the Tampa market for customer service and provider relationships. Devoted's HMO plans emphasize care coordination and often feature competitive star ratings.
Simply Healthcare (a Centene company) specializes in Florida Medicaid and Medicare populations, offering D-SNP and standard HMO plans designed for the state's diverse senior population. Simply Healthcare is particularly strong in serving Spanish-speaking and low-income communities in Hillsborough.
| Carrier | Plan Types | Est. Premium Range | MOOP (In-Network) | Notable Strengths |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| BCBS FL (Florida Blue) | HMO, PPO | $0 – $90/mo | $3,900 – $7,550 | Broadest network, PPO flexibility, Moffitt access |
| Humana | HMO, PPO, D-SNP | $0 – $65/mo | $3,400 – $7,550 | $0 premium HMOs, OTC allowance, transportation |
| UnitedHealthcare (AARP) | HMO, PPO, D-SNP | $0 – $95/mo | $3,900 – $7,550 | Optum network, Renew Active, strong drug coverage |
| Aetna (CVS Health) | HMO, PPO, D-SNP | $0 – $60/mo | $3,500 – $7,550 | CVS pharmacy integration, dental/vision/hearing |
| Molina Healthcare | HMO, D-SNP | $0/mo | $3,500 – $7,550 | D-SNP focus, OTC, care coordination |
| Devoted Health | HMO | $0 – $40/mo | $3,400 – $6,700 | High star ratings, personalized care, dental |
| Simply Healthcare | HMO, D-SNP | $0/mo | $3,500 – $7,550 | Multilingual support, D-SNP, OTC benefits |
Figures are estimates based on 2026 plan data. Verify current plans at Medicare.gov or call .
One of Hillsborough County's greatest Medicare advantages is its hospital landscape. Most major plans include the key systems, but there are important nuances to understand before you enroll.
BayCare Health System operates St. Joseph's Hospital, Mease Countryside (Pinellas), and several other facilities in the Tampa Bay region. BayCare is widely in-network across most Hillsborough MA plans, but confirm Pinellas County BayCare facilities are in-network if you live near the county line.
Tampa General Hospital is a Level I trauma center and academic medical center affiliated with USF Health. It is in-network for most plans, but specialty services (transplant, cancer, etc.) may have specific coverage rules — always verify in advance.
Moffitt Cancer Center is one of the nation's top cancer research hospitals and is located in Tampa. Cancer patients on Medicare Advantage should verify that Moffitt is in-network for their chosen plan, or consider whether a PPO's out-of-network coverage is necessary.
HCA Florida Brandon Hospital and other HCA facilities are generally well-covered. AdventHealth Tampa is also included in most networks.
Hillsborough County has a significant population of low-income seniors who qualify for both Medicare and Florida Medicaid. D-SNP plans in Tampa are among the most generously funded in Florida due to the large and competitive dual-eligible population in the market.
Available D-SNP carriers in Hillsborough County include Humana, Aetna, Molina Healthcare, UnitedHealthcare, and Simply Healthcare. Benefits commonly include:
To enroll in a D-SNP, you must currently be enrolled in Florida Medicaid. D-SNP enrollment is available year-round for those who qualify, not just during the annual Open Enrollment Period.
With seven carriers in the market, the Part D formulary differences in Hillsborough County are meaningful. Two plans with the same $0 premium can have dramatically different drug costs depending on how your medications are tiered.
A strategic approach to drug coverage in Hillsborough:
With such a strong healthcare infrastructure in Tampa, Original Medicare also works very well here. Any Medicare-participating provider in the county will accept Original Medicare, giving you access to the full depth of Tampa's medical community without network restrictions.
Medicare Advantage wins when you want the extra benefits — dental, vision, drug coverage, OTC, fitness — bundled with lower or $0 premiums. The trade-off is network restrictions, prior authorization requirements for some procedures, and the fact that out-of-area coverage is typically limited to emergencies.
Original Medicare plus a Medigap supplement plan wins when you want unlimited provider access, predictable out-of-pocket costs, and freedom from prior authorization hurdles. The premium is higher (typically $150 to $250+ per month for Medigap, plus Part D) but the coverage is more consistent and portable.
For most healthy Medicare beneficiaries in Tampa who stay local and use their coverage moderately, a well-chosen Medicare Advantage plan offers excellent value. For those with complex, multi-specialist care needs or who travel frequently, the Original Medicare + Medigap combination deserves serious comparison.
With seven carriers and dozens of plan options, Hillsborough County requires a disciplined selection process. Here is a practical approach:
Get personalized plan recommendations from a licensed Florida Medicare specialist. No cost, no obligation.
Compare Plans Now →